I follow him and *greet* him before he steps outside. The most popular theory is that Krall was a Gorn, a lizard-like alien species that Kirk and the Enterprise crew defeated in the original Star, Where should I go to sell my Hummel figurines? While talking to Ross, he says something like: "First it was Bill, then Javier, now Dutch. He spills the beans on some pretty personal . We wouldnt be here if it werent for him. The best selection of games which will be released in 2022 and 2023 for PC, PS5, PS4, Xbox Series X/S, Xbox One, Switch - and you can watch in amazing 4K ULTRA HD and 60FPS quality with latest updates about all of the games in this list! Said it in General but I'll post it again here-, Well John does vaguely allude to other gang members in RDR. And maybe Arthur is hiding as well (obviously somewhere else and not on the ranch), and Ross caught wind of that. i agree with what others said. | Privacy Policy | Contact Us| About Us|. he made it out and shacked up in Bolivia. and our Cutter De Blanc, Where did all that money go by RDR1? Arthur Morgan (Red Dead) - Wikipedia Ive completed the main story and epilogue for RDR2 months ago, and have been playing the Endless Summer nightly ever since (when Im not online). Also, possibly him not wanting to link the name of arthur morgan with the bad reputation that dutch, bill, and javier had by that point in time. But your father dont like to talk about him. Isgho Votre ducation notre priorit . The rest of the crew is probably long dead. The gang is composed by dozens and dozens of people so why would he be mentioned in particular? Not all the new gang members need to die in RDR II, He didn't exactly have any time to sit and chit chat with Dutch reminiscing on old times. Why Red Dead Redemption Is Even Sadder After Playing RDR2 - Screen Rant I (John) walk in and join them. Great summary, no need to preorder this game now. Micah then flees in enrage, while Arthur dies of tuberculosis while watching the sun rise from the mountainside. From what we've read from the previews, I think that's all dependent of the player. (Looks at me) Do you, John?, JOHN: (pause) No. They had to return to America broke, taking odd jobs in Strawberry and then Pronghorn Ranch. Why does John Marston never mention Arthur Morgan in Red Dead - Quora If you let him go, he'll run away. Only one I remember from rdr1 was bill and Dutch. or maybe. why is arthur not mentioned in rdr1 - khushboocatering.com By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. How hards that to grasp for some. However, as John, I have been all over that area bounty hunting and animal hunting, so his aforementioned statement doesn't seem true. So why is arthur morgan never mentioned in rdr1 if him and johr were pretty close. Would he have steered Dutch right? Theories on why Arthur isn't mentioned in RDR - Reddit The problem is . The closest RDR was to mentioning Arthur was when John speaks to Bonnie saying a "friend" aka Arthur helped him escape the gang life. By 1911, he's not mentioned at all, which does make sense in some ways because, as said, he went down in history as one of a group and anything he did was thought to have been done by the gang as a whole. may not be appropriate for all ages, or may not be appropriate for viewing at work. Youll have to use a few of the games bugs. why is arthur not mentioned in rdr1 John says, "Imma curb stomp that rat!" 24. level 2. Maybe The Strange Man, telling John that "he has forgotten so many important people", is a hint on John pretending he doesn't know who or where Uncle and Arthur (and possibly other gang members) are. Which he does say at point I'm the ending of rdr2 talking to strangers. This is over.". I follow him and *greet* him before he steps outside. How often do you talk about former workmates to people you just met? The IRL reason, of course, is that Arthur was not created until RDR2. GTA Online New Bonuses for 27th April 2023 - The Last Dose Hard Mode Event is here alongside rewards for completing the missions and extra payouts, the Issi Rally is back, and more! We do get to see how being part of the Van der Linde Gang has affected this much younger John. "There's no news coverage. Your email address will not be published. See you guys in the next one! Here are my thoughts: We know for a fact that time travel and aliens and a whole host of weird shit exists in this universe, and this theory just relies on us seeing an alternate reality with at least one extra person in the Van der Linde gang, so it's kind of less far fetched than all that other stuff. Ross only cared about wiping out the members that could effect Nate Johns candidacy, so he would not send John off to track down some low level gang member who might have fled to the other side of the country. As it says the title, let's speculate why Arthur is not even mentioned in Red Dead Redemption 1 by John Marston, as far we know now, Arthur is the enforcer and like "the big brother" that looks after the gang, why in the original RDR (based 12 years later) is like he never existed? For more information, please see our Ive spent a lot of time at the ranch with the Marston Family. UltraGizmo64 and. Or something like that. The graphics were great but the story sucked." Why do they never mention Arthur Morgan in RDR1? ^ Yeah. probably not in a hurry to think about any other former gang members. Who is Arthur Morgan based off of? TL;DR In RDR1, John doesnt mention Arthur because 1) it hurts him to think of him, 2) hes ashamed that Arthur saved his family, and 3) he said not to look back. rdr2 pc teleport mod Sign up for a new account in our community. im thinking either. There's also a dozen other characters who've been added to the canon and who haven't been accounted for in RDR. Why is so necessary to remove all realism from the game? Need help with all Achievements optimization, Gambit has no direction and that is why it has failed, Shattered Realm was criminally underrated as a Seasonal Activity and as a concept, Heavy weapons and how to make the best use of them in survival, I Hope That Necrom Does What Elsweyr Did: A Synopsis of Masterful Storytelling. To be honest, despite the screens we've seen of John so far, it could be possibility that he and Morgan won't actually interact that much. Do you think RDR2 was a good RDR1 prequel? | ResetEra It seems more likely to me given the fact that we see the world of RDR2 populated with aliens, time travelers and ghosts that John never mentions Arthur, Hosea, Sadie or Micah ever in RDR1 because they never existed in RDR1 John's timeline than because he forgot or just didn't like talking about it. But with the whole rdr2 as a whole there is a lot of inconsistencies between the two games, but theres some you can piece together. Not all the new gang members need to die in RDR II, [] so he (Ross) would not send John off to track down some low level gang member who might have fled to the other side of the country. Don't warn me again for Red Dead Redemption 2. The REAL Reason Why Arthur Morgan Is NEVER Mentioned In The - YouTube Maybe he changed his identity like Micheal did in GTA V? Wild Mint is extremely common to find near streams, marshes and moist meadows all over the map. haven't played rdr in forever. How do I track animals using my binoculars? he figured if the government didint mention them then he wasent going to bring them up. In rdr1, Arthur Morgan was never mentioned. how to save arthur morgan from tuberculosis; is jay north married; Well-known antique/collectible publications (classified ads section) Hummel collector club, The main advantage of having a south-facing home or garden is the amount of light youll get. Espaol - Latinoamrica (Spanish - Latin America). If Redemption 1 had been Redemption 2, then yes. GTANet.com 2001-2023. How do I take cover by the door while trying to save Javier in chapter 5? Unlike the morally-neutral but honorable family man we see in RDR1, John is much colder. TL;DR John doesnt mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) Hes ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back. They were basically brothers. By Most of what Arthur did was considered an action of the gang as a whole, not just him. The point is, the writers didnt lazily ignore the fact that John didnt mention Arthur in RDR1. Red Dead Redemption: Game of the Year Edition - amazon.com This means that a north wind blows from the north,, Anything goes with stone, black, white, coral, aqua, any shade of blue, baby pink, hot pink, emerald green, olive green, and red. If RDR 1 did have any references to RDR 2, realistically speaking, Arthur wouldnt actually be a likely choice. Here are the best content by the team thcsnguyenthanhson.edu.vn synthesize and compile, see more in the section How. What happened to the dog in Red Dead Redemption 2? I found that to be reason enough. I think Arthur will be like an older brother to John, never turn his back on him and will go on to live a peaceful life on a ranch somewhere in the end and was never mentioned because john had no resentment towards Arthur warranting redemption unlike the other gang members. The past is behind us now. I clarified that this is the STORY reason, not the IRL reason. gosh who also wants a RDR1 remaster now??lol. Jack and Abigail sit in the living room. In rdr1, Arthur Morgan was never mentioned. Reddit and its partners use cookies and similar technologies to provide you with a better experience. TL;DR - John doesnt mention Arthur in RDR1 because 1) It hurts him to think of Arthur, 2) Hes ashamed that Arthur saved his family, 3) Arthur said to not look back. Because John Was Only After The Ones Who Went Crazy And Left Him For Dead. Cookie Notice Throughout the game's six chapters, Arthur develops quite a bit more than John ever did. Then he left the gang because of how Dutch and Others Went Crazy And Uncontrollable. Sorry . Arthur Morgan may not be a good person in a lot of ways, but he certainly cared deeply for little Jack. EDIT: To all the people saying Arthur wasnt created until RDR2, thats why, you're missing the point. He has a rich arc full of ups and downs . There was some vague preproductions and character backstories, but I don't think Aurthur was even conceived of as a character during the development of the first game. While Hosea wouldve been a little bit more well-known than him, the gang member with the most fame after Dutch would have been Micah, who became very well-known in 1907 for his reign of terror and mysterious death. Remember, Morgan's the gang second in command and he also has to take of said gang, which means he'll most likely (or we will) try to keep our group tight. Arthur did save us. Because they made RDR1 before RDR2? Because Arthur, as Sean puts it, is a skeptic. After how grateful he was to Arthur at the end of chapter 6, makes him feel disrespectful. Is RDR2 based on a true story? - InfoBG.NET Member. how to save arthur morgan from tuberculosis - hrts.com.mx In this case, Arthur abandons John in order to return to the gangs burning camp. Required fields are marked *. It's easy! Anyone playing RDR1 after RDR2 is going to be very confused whenever John speaks about his past. There's very little reason to mention anyone else than the people he's hunting down. As others gave stated there us no mention of Arthur. This hidden portion of the map is highly likely to be playable later, either in Red Dead Online mode or as a result of an expansion. A lot of the memories would also probably be unpleasant, given that he was left for dead. The point is, the writers didnt lazily ignore the fact that John didnt mention Arthur in RDR1. He might have let slip once that any of the hugely influential RDR2 characters existed at all, but he never does because he never knew them. Scan this QR code to download the app now. Arthur morgan never mentioned in rdr1 : r/reddeadredemption EDIT: To all the people saying "Arthur wasn't created until RDR2, that's why," you're missing the point. It could just be that Morgan did right by Marston at the end, and he had no beef with Morgan. Im six hours in and Im liking every minute. gamespot.comgiantbomb.commetacritic.comfandom.comfanatical.com, Privacy PolicyCookie SettingsDo Not Sell My InformationReportAd. Im certainly not in favour of changing the story in RDR 1 just to include a mention of Arthur, but nonetheless, a newspaper scrap or something that can be found somewhere remote with a comment from John would be interesting and ultimately all that is needed. Is so I can farm dem v-bucks for BR skins At least that was my intention at first when I bought STW but then I got addicted a little bit, which was quick for me since I love looting games Borderlands series, Diablo, WoW stuff like that What can I say.. if game bases around, Alot of people including myself wonder what would happen if Arthur didn't get TB. Is Arthur mentioned in rdr1? Oct 25, 2017 Bill and Javier didnt get the focus and screen-time they deserved in RDR 2. By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. Its clear that Jack still remembers Arthur and adores him. We wouldnt be here if it werent for him. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. Of course, the IRL reason is that Arthur wasn't created until RDR2. The gang is composed by dozens and dozens of people so why would he be mentioned in particular? The Blackwater Massacre was an infamous and violent gunfight involving the Van der Linde gang, the Blackwater Police Department, the Pinkerton National Detective Agency and supposedly the famous gunslinger Landon Ricketts, which took place in the town of Blackwater in May 1899 during a robbery on a nearby ferry. Only one I remember from rdr1 was bill and Dutch. The ring John uses to propose to Abigail is Arthur's old wedding ring, and after Arthur dies John begins journaling in an effort to help keep his memory alive. During the mission " Political Realities in Armadillo " John tells the Marshal " You know, I hear you speak and suddenly, I'm reminded of how some of the people I respected the most in my life had a problem with authority ". Also, why is Arthur not mentioned in rdr1? "Nobody talks about it," Holmes said. Arthur gave them the money to flee and start over, which turned out to be money wasted because their new life prospecting in the Tundra failed. No looking back., (Jack gets up and walks out. slimeball supreme and, AnthMUFC-Champs, how do you make wheel in little alchemy; what does miss honey describe as her greatest triumph Open menu. Why can't I speak to any NPC or interact with my horse? 22 How To Rob Bank Rdr2 Ultimate Guide 04/2023 John in the first RDR was kind of evasive about any topic that pertained to the gang. [Solved] 2. Is the graph created a complete graph? Why or why not? 3 Any theories? They addressed it through story and character in many subtle ways to discover, rather than a single throwaway line. I Wish Infected Was A Permanent Featured Playlist Game A good summary of the whole ending. The one he wears in the first game, in particular. Your email address will not be published. 2. So I was kinda curious too why Arthur wasn't mentioned. By accepting all cookies, you agree to our use of cookies to deliver and maintain our services and site, improve the quality of Reddit, personalize Reddit content and advertising, and measure the effectiveness of advertising. He lassos Arthur, and the mission instructions at the bottom of the screen read, "Find a curb," but while he's looking all over town to try to find a curb in 1899, the mission timer times out, and Arthur gets away, starting a new underground life. All rights reserved. We also know that alternate timelines have been explored in the Red Dead universe. You need to be a member in order to leave a comment. There are clever retconned reasons for it. Little moments like the one above are worth discussing. Arthur wasn't planned until the development of rdr2. Because his character was probably created after RDR1 was completed. I especially like seeing Arthur Morgans interactions with the gang. Because John never mentions him, Arthur Morgan and his story are eventually lost to history. Red Dead Redemption 2; All Activity; Home ; Red Dead ; Red Dead Redemption 2 [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1? Do you think they should've mentioned Arthur on rdr1? | Fandom Presumably, John hadnt had anything to do with Arthur for something like 5-10 years by the time of RDR1. My point is: There's no particular reason for him not being mentioned. 1907 Roleplay REDM Hiring Admins, Serious Roleplay, Active Development. In RDR1 the Pinkerton Agency was simply interested to use John to catch former gang brothers who were operating arround the boarder area, namely WIlliamson, Escuela and Dutch. The point is, the writers didn't lazily ignore the fact that John didn't mention Arthur in RDR1. 1/5/2021. "Knowing what we know, we can't figure out how the GT-R goes around the Nurburgring so fast." Abigail is sewing while Jack reads a book. [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1? So, they probably weren't expecting to return to it. JACK: (remembering) Arthur! It's because he doesn't exist in RDR1's timeline. By 1911, hes not mentioned at all, which does make sense in some ways because, as said, he went down in history as one of a group and anything he did was thought to have been done by the gang as a whole. To me that says that other gang members are still alive, but not a priority (or not as well known to the public) for John to track them down. MARKUS. either way hopefully it will all be explained in rdr 2. You're browsing the GameFAQs Message Boards as a guest. Then who?" Privacy Policy. Best Work Writer's Discussion 2016 [The "I Love Karen Daniels" fanfic]. (Spoilers) Why Arthur is not mentioned RDR1. - Reddit [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1? By rejecting non-essential cookies, Reddit may still use certain cookies to ensure the proper functionality of our platform. There are, to my knowledge, no supernatural occurances in RDR1 apart from possibly the Stranger, and even he might be explained by misfiring bullets and a network of intelligence contacts. Because John never mentions him, Arthur Morgan and his story are eventually lost to history. It's part of what makes this such a good game, that famous attention to detail. He eventually gets it together, but in the meantime, Jack finds a sort of father figure in Arthur Morgan. So, if its going to reference anyone, then it should be him. Can you go to Mexico in rdr2? Why do they never mention Arthur Morgan in RDR1? - Steam Community Maybe arthur, along with the others moved far away and wasn't in the fbi/pinkertons jurisdiction. I came up with a theory on what would happen if Mr. Downes didn't spit on our Boah., I just finished Far Cry 5 and my only question is Why? Cancel. But John was always very vague about his past throughout Red Dead Redemption. Conclusion: RDR2 takes in an alternate timeline from RDR1, possibly distinguishable primarily by the absence or presence of Arthur Morgan. Jack and Abigail sit in the living room. burger_mike and, saintsrow, Valve Corporation. Would he have helped John and his family? He tells people that he was in a gang with Dutch, Bill and Javier, they left him for dead in a botched robbery and he left the gang. May 9, 2018 in Red Dead Redemption 2. Is Johns Hat Arthurs Hat - Clothes Questions Karen Jones. Companion theory: RDR2 and Undead Nightmare take place in the same timeline, separate from RDR1. Our old protagonist from RDR1, who lets Arthur Morgan take the wheel in RDR2. I already feel satisfied. JACK: (remembering) Arthur! in his new life as a Blackwater bank accountant, that would give him away, like what happened to Michael in GTAV. Or is it just that rockstar didnt think of arthur at the time of making rdr1? Ultimately the decision does not matter. [Speculation Topic] Why Arthur is not mentioned in RDR1? If you dont want any spoilers then just play the game to the end and you will find your answer. He gives the barest of details to everyone. Why is Arthur not mentioned in RDR1? Mr Van der Linde - Chapter 6 - dutchvanwinkle - Red Dead Redemption Red Dead Redemption 2: 20 Wild Details About Arthur Morgan - Screen Rant Well, it's very obvious the real reason is because Arthur wasn't even imagined until the release of the first game. You could have just predicted the whole plot of RDR2. He isn't as devoted to his family, and he struggles to deal with the gang's . ), JOHN: You know, I did a little saving you myself., JOHN: (pointedly) Youre my family, boy., (Jack leaves. He took inspiration from Toshiro Mifune, John Wayne, and Rob Wiethoff, all of whom played John Marston in the game and its sequel. Red Dead Wiki is a FANDOM Games Community. The south side of any house will receive, The direction from which wind blows (such as the north wind) is named after it. I clarified that this is the STORY reason, not the IRL reason. By 1911, he's not mentioned at all, which does make sense in some ways because, as said, he went down in history as one of a group and anything he did was thought to have been done by the gang as a whole. That something is redemption for all of his gang members, and Arthur is his most important. RubyLane is an internet site. It seems more likely to me given the fact that we see the world of RDR2 populated with aliens, time travelers and ghosts that John never mentions Arthur, Hosea, Sadie or Micah ever in RDR1 because they never existed in RDR1 John's timeline than because he forgot or just didn't like talking about it. nicktestbranch, TL;DR - In RDR1, John doesn't mention Arthur because 1) it hurts him to think of him, 2) he's ashamed that Arthur saved his family, and 3) he said not to look back. Is the money still in the cave rdr2? They addressed it through story and character in many subtle ways to discover, rather than a single throwaway line. (Looks at me) Do you, John?, JOHN: (pause) No. DON'T MISS YOUR RIDE! The REAL Reason Why Arthur Morgan Is NEVER Mentioned In The First Red Dead Redemption Game! Luckily for Arthur, in 1899 there's no TV where he can can be heard yelling "Where's Ah Munneh???" Ever wondered why Arthur is never mentioned in RDR1?