The goal of discrimination training is to teach the child to discriminate between items, labels, names, etc. TPT empowers educators to teach at their best. Reinforcing the child when they ask natural questions to increase the likelihood that they will increase this behavior (i.e. (/. In ABA, or Applied Behavior Analysis, discrimination training is a program for all ages, however, it is particularly helpful and effective for children. David L. Hull, Rodney E. Langman and Sigrid S. Glenn have developed this parallel in detail. The first format is an individual question presentation with five answer choices. We aim to provide a wide range of injection molding services and products ranging from complete molding project management customized to your needs. As success shows, the child is then asked to select the shoe when next to a spoon and a toy, for example. WebFor example What do you see in the park? List of What Questions about objects with possible answers What do you find in the bedroom? [16] The authors contrived motivating operations for objects by training behavior chains that could not be completed without certain objects. ), singing songs, or answering questions (e.g., saying Good when hearing How are you?). In other words, intraverbals are our basic conversational skills. [17], Chapter Five of Verbal Behavior discusses the tact in depth. Intraverbals are a big part of teaching conversational skills, so this video is all about assessing and teaching this important communication skill. Skinner notes in this chapter how any given response is likely to be the result of multiple variables. Drawing on the results of these studies, applied behavior analysts create personalized intervention programs for each child and collaborate with other professionals to advance the techniques used in the field. Click the card to flip Definition 1 / 10 syrup and sausage Click the card to flip Flashcards Learn Test Echoic: the repeating of a sound or word when present with the discriminative stimulus (SD) of say. An intraverbalallows children to answer questions, discuss items that arent present and are an essential part of conversations and social interactions. For example roll and throw are different actions, but both can be done with a ball. You may start with only one item on the table once you've figured out how to connect actions and objects in your instructions. Children with autism generally work with therapists for several hours each week, and progress could take weeks, or even months, to appear. WebIts important for applied behavior analysts to fully grasp B.F. Skinners 4 primary functions of communication to meet these challenges. Water! WebSensory stimulus serves as discriminative stimulus. endobj This analysis extends Ernst Mach's pragmatic inductive position in physics, and extends even further a disinclination towards hypothesis-making and testing. The number of objects, or "distractors," that are out, the scanning area, and the cleanliness of the area all impact the complexity of the task. An important class of examples of intraverbal control is that of verbal conditional discriminations (Axe, 2008; Eikeseth & Smith, 2013; Sundberg & Sundberg, 2011 ). Speak to one of our enrollment advisors to learn more about how you can get yourMasters in Behavior Analysis onlinedegree. Chomsky's review has come to be regarded as one of the foundational documents of the discipline of cognitive psychology, and even after the passage of twenty-five years it is considered the most important refutation of behaviorism. xZ[~_e@6!-e7R]d=',@O*c.gs~1pyo~8ze9dmP+2 l{u]_x=u>yy 26kD.ndy/W][*UU-SU=|X:I3yrK y)[8Wd.K,C!3xs)#.s$X?|g$x*S4M,%P-Pe_M.2E@SP&*4TZ`1f Again, the speaker is Sammy. Skinner, B.F. (1983) A Matter of Consequences. What animal has a Add highlights, virtual manipulatives, and more. The special audience in this case is one concerned with "successful action". Will My Child Be Ready for School In the Fall? Webechoics, intraverbals, tacts, textuals, and transcriptions produces generalized conditioned reinforcement (gscr-praise, attention) example of echoic Parent (reading with child): That's a bear. How is My Kindergartener Doing in School? In the third example, a mother asks her son how he did on a major project that was supposed to be turned in later on that day. Complete the form to download the brochure. u)(S J.jB((P,P By using discrimination training to teach a variety of tasks it becomes a generalized skill. Repeating a formula, reciting a poem, and so on. The basic skills required for discrimination training include: Discrimination training is conducted by the presentation of the desired item to teach, for example; a shoe. Be aware of the differences between the objects when training a child to differentiate between them. ozB6/=|[#eYK7,t&Xl/}'^`&Kd,ZA.=hZ#%7O, Ah[9N:=TKR@ (il K/QnS4{[lw|gV:} QWQ\r>,\-7%?/^M%y 3kAyl=rmwy8#mhHV/@W7>a9&/y"tt8# L*ND_"J1bPZe\AGjUtW/CsVQWd=nfh4!zS1'kl7fRB[5*)$gJu=nhQs??F2n;estt\En%TaZ$:7izuVLneTkp_}2"!#|g&rk.F:6{7-:9R}[Xr7:u i,S$m }s9QL; a Gx#nXxDS084V+oUr]`j}C Autoclitic: a complex verbal operant. Such a formulation permits us to apply to verbal behavior concepts and laws which emerge from a more general analysis" (p. Intraverbal: the filling in the blank. A response given quickly when prompted forms the basis for inferring a high strength. An organism responds similarly to both private stimuli and public stimuli (Skinner, 1957, p.130). [2] "oh, no" she groaned "Oh, no! They also have a widespread peer acceptance, which is valuable. These challenges are varied and can correlate to distinct issues. [1][14] The first chapter sets the stage for this work, a functional analysis of verbal behavior. WebThe child will intraverbally respond to 25 different song fill-in-the-blanks, animal sounds, or fun fill-in verbal stimuli. There are two different modalities involved ("reading"). xX[o6~7p"fxqX-;F%EQw%z8 ? Skinner notes that while audience control is developed due to histories with certain audiences, we do not have to have a long history with every listener in order to effectively engage in verbal behavior in their presence (p.176). One form is textual behavior which refers to the type of behavior we might typically call reading or writing. eventually child learns to identify bear without this prompt The following table[20] summarizes the new verbal operants in the analysis of verbal behavior. Repetition is essential for learning a new topic, however, it is important that the repetitions have slight variations. He suggests the most frequent method is via "a common public accompaniment". When teaching a label, for example, you normally want a significant distinction between the objects you're showing. While SB systems like PECS may be easier for motor impairments to learn, more response effort is required. Unusual or difficult conditions would tend to lend evidence to the inference of strength. 'kx%`W/j8AW)xawp 1AdJFH:Yi--UWFZm_LN%w _@9) [44] In Skinner's essay, Selection by Consequences he argued that operant conditioning was a part of a three-level process involving genetic evolution, cultural evolution and operant conditioning. WebTwo formats are provided. Its important for applied behavior analysts to fully grasp B.F. Skinners 4 primary functions of communication to meet these challenges. 2533 The verbal behavior intervention works on developing certain communication skills. Receptive language is the other component of verbal behavioral training that is necessary for discrimination training. having multiple possible relationships depending on the circumstances). [4] This tradition has continued. Research shows that various AAC interventions can be effective in helping children with communication challenges learn how to interact with family, friends, and acquaintances. Some of the challenges may include difficulty processing auditory information, limited speaking skills, difficulty understanding the meaning and rhythm of words and phrases, and difficulty deciphering body language. I absolutely love that this is also aligned with ABLLS. Also research is presented at poster sessions and conferences, such as at regional Behavior Analysis conventions[38] or Association for Behavior Analysis (ABA)[39] conventions nationally or internationally. Content Area 9: Behavior Change Procedures 9-25 Use language acquisition programs that employ Skinners analysis of verbal behavior (i.e., echoics, mands, tacts, intraverbals). In other words, 91 0 obj << /Linearized 1 /O 93 /H [ 781 480 ] /L 140966 /E 17176 /N 24 /T 139028 >> endobj xref 91 17 0000000016 00000 n 0000000688 00000 n 0000001261 00000 n 0000001443 00000 n 0000001651 00000 n 0000001691 00000 n 0000001798 00000 n 0000001903 00000 n 0000003307 00000 n 0000003722 00000 n 0000003825 00000 n 0000004501 00000 n 0000005433 00000 n 0000014240 00000 n 0000014319 00000 n 0000000781 00000 n 0000001239 00000 n trailer << /Size 108 /Info 89 0 R /Root 92 0 R /Prev 139018 /ID[<4b2f30a200c3baecb7630246cf42cc70><1aee068738457d9bcaa6ca282c43b47d>] >> startxref 0 %%EOF 92 0 obj << /Type /Catalog /Pages 86 0 R /Metadata 90 0 R /PageLabels 84 0 R >> endobj 106 0 obj << /S 414 /L 483 /Filter /FlateDecode /Length 107 0 R >> stream Web3-18 Define and provide examples of intraverbals. In order for discrimination training to be effective, there must be a connection between the therapist and the child a level of trust and understanding. Skinner's Verbal Behavior also introduced the autoclitic and six elementary operants: mand, tact, audience relation, echoic, textual, and intraverbal. An autoclitic provides more information to a statement such as I think, I see, I want, I hear, etc. (bed, nightstand, pillow, carpet, WebAn intraverbal allows children to answer questions, discuss items that arent present and are an essential part of conversations and social interactions. An energetic and strong. HxOaYAY| vZBSG`Sm=NgbrhV44?zj"Nn7R+.6YH0}'O*FUL: Veb $#~Ib2eVE+)>Io3%Ic'uAuTwuFDt/tK@cDTK,Ka|1YMcKSli-Z|Jz5&y8rxoP[>$P#qK0c7:v}mh(l6ibNR3 z@#9CvYGix${FSPy+0l@R Cb \iW-/kJ_^BMiW6y9USAGMp'f(q_LsUyhDbRV5r9h6 o;db>4[} q!+ay2r pA"^YbA9pZs?HLr/+.#IV5qmuCj5~mu %]t{o0w#SdBV!e0{Edg-q"IRXXd'zl^?1[7=64MRiw6&. WebIntraverbal (LEVEL 2, Milestone 6) IV 2.6M: Completes 10 different fill-in-the blank phrases of any types (e.g., song fill-ins, social games and fun fill-ins or object sounds) TARGET For example, if a child verbally states, "a circle" when a circle is in the immediate environment, it may be a tact. Picture prompts are provide for instruction but should be faded as soon as students begin to gain intraverbal skills. Discrimination training, like other ABA training methods, requires time. The communication method is also fairly simple, and there are high-tech and low-tech options available for use. Hb```"^ 9b@@ &|NQ>!ER}?2cpA endobj Sign language works because it facilitates efficient responses, its comprehensive, and its topography based. E*HRB"E@}D~0BY8,2Q *VYPPaP Two formats are provided. The logical and scientific community also sharpens responses to assure accuracy and avoiding distortion. Example in everyday context: You smell a baked goods as you walk down your street. A special case of where multiple causation comes into play creating new verbal forms is in what Skinner describes as fragmentary responses. WebFor example; a red ball will elicit a response of ball or red ball. [45] This topic continues to be a focus for behavior analysts. The origin of Verbal Behavior was an outgrowth of a series of lectures first presented at the University of Minnesota in the early 1940s and developed further in his summer lectures at Columbia and William James lectures at Harvard in the decade before the book's publication. The verbal community shapes the original development and the maintenance or discontinuation of the tacts for private events (Catania, 2007, p.232). These functions consist of mand (requesting), tact (labeling), intraverbal (associations and answering questions), and echoic (parroting and vocal imitation). Fatigue, illness and insobriety may tend to produce fragmentary responding. Fill out the form to learn more about our program options or get started on your application today. The consequences of the response are the third term, and whether or not those consequences strengthen or weaken the response will affect whether that response will occur again in the presence of that audience. Secondly, that any given variable usually affects multiple responses. WebEXAMPLES : [1] Dr. Lynn Block, director of research for the Larson Soap Company, looked at her appointment book book. Shirt, pants, socks, belt Name some furniture. Pre-made digital activities. Rather than thinking of words as labels for things, the objective is to assist children in understanding how to use language to communicate ideas and express themselves. Such combinations are typically vocal, although this may be due to different conditions of self-editing rather than any special property. An audience that has punished certain kinds of verbal behavior is called a negative audience (p.178): in the presence of this audience, the punished verbal behavior is less likely to occur. [36], Current research in verbal behavior is published in The Analysis of Verbal Behavior[37] (TAVB), and other Behavior Analytic journals such as The Journal of the Experimental Analysis of Behavior (JEAB) and the Journal of Applied Behavior Analysis (JABA). This instruction aims to educate children with autism to think in terms other than language. (^!h~R%JV-bgV_pYd-ZY5K#ZJDj?Dk%JVh ],Q-@'Sy%$G}B/)Y!Z(V{bm [18], Intraverbals are verbal behavior under the control of other verbal behavior. As a result, while teaching "vehicle," you may also have the choice of teaching "horse," "chair," or "ball". The third way is when the verbal community provides reinforcement contingent on the overt behavior and the organism generalizes that to the private event that is occurring. 4 0 obj Then, as the child gains this skill, you may offer more similar alternatives, such as the bus, bicycle, motorbike, or train objects with less distinction from a vehicle. A mand is typically a demand, command, or request. The final method that Skinner suggests may help form our verbal behavior is when the behavior is initially at a low level and then turns into a private event (Skinner, 1957, p.134). An important class of examples of intraverbal control is that of verbal conditional discriminations (Axe, 2008; Eikeseth & Smith, 2013; Sundberg & Sundberg, &cB:):YkXyzy0Ps3VIBS5j!,C#t7wqf: x.> zN1ON#WSY The controlling stimulus is nonverbal, "the whole of the physical environment". <> Of all his writings, it was the Skinner review which contributed most to spreading his reputation beyond the small circle of professional linguists. For example, during receptive labeling, you should not use the same photo over and over to teach the identification of a dog. Car, van, bus, truck Name some jewelry. An intraverbal is an exchange or a conversation. - Here are a few Do Nots: Do not begin teaching intraverbals too early, or at too high of a difficulty level. Do not completely avoid teaching intraverbals they're the building blocks of conversation. Do not begin teaching intraverbals before echolalia is under control. Its also considered useful for transitioning to an SGD. T1-b: The child will spontaneously tact (no verbal prompts) at least 10 different items in a day. [12] For Skinner, the proper object of study is behavior itself, analyzed without reference to hypothetical (mental) structures, but rather with reference to the functional relationships of the behavior in the environment in which it occurs. Emission If a response is emitted it may tend to be interpreted as having some strength. when asked. Skinner presents verbal behavior as a function of controlling consequences and stimuli, not as the product of a special inherent capacity. Neither does he ask us to be satisfied with simply describing the structure, or patterns, of behavior. Another thing to think about is what the child will see in their field of vision as they respond to your inquiry. New York: Knopf. Speed Speed is the speed of the response itself, or the latency from the time in which it could have occurred to the time in which it occurs. That being said, the expensive high-tech communication tools restrict access to advanced communication. Quizzes with auto-grading, and real-time student data. However, SGDs typically require additional materials for communication. Intraverbal: the filling in the blank. For example, a math word problem that provides several clues to seek one final answer is an example of convergent control. Simply, this is whether or not the child can follow simple directions will the child understand that the word "cup" refers to the thing we use to consume liquids if the therapist asks for a cup. In Chapter Four Skinner notes forms of control by verbal stimuli. A 2013 study found PECS and SGDs to be equally effective in teaching requesting skills to children with autism. The Association for Science in Autism Treatment defines PECS as a methodology that use pictures and other symbols to develop a functional communication system for individuals with autism spectrum disorder (ASD) based upon the principles of applied behavior analysis (ABA). Another type of AAC, SGDs are machines that produce voice output. Child: bear Parent: great job! Mand, tact, echoic, intraverbal, and autoclitic are verbal operants. [13] Verbal Behavior is divided into 5 parts with 19 chapters. According to a meta-analysis study published in Neuropsychiatric Disease and Treatment, The first three stages of PECS are effective and teaching children to request preferred items. This is backed by various forms of data: In a 2007 study, for instance, SGDs when used with naturalistic instructional strategies improved communication in students with disabilities. Energy-level Unlike emission as a basis for inference, energy-level (response magnitude) provides a basis for inferring the response has a strength with a high range of varying strength. "; groaned. Who do you see when youre sick? (doctor), When do you eat breakfast? (morning) etc. Children with autism may need extra guidance when learning to communicate. <> WebMuch of our day-to-day verbal interactionwith each other involves intraverbal behav-ior. The techniques are manipulating stimuli, changing the level of editing, the mechanical production of verbal behavior, changing motivational and emotional variables, incubation, and so on. Issues of multiple control, and involving many of the elementary operants stated in previous chapters are discussed. Applied behavior analysts must consider childrens specific learning, communication, and behavioral challenges when formulating an AAC intervention plan, they must also collaborate with speech-language pathologists to determine the most appropriate means of teaching communication. OHB"E(PH(!P&*4,(4!PX,KA*TSBAeA2KQ It may be more difficult to shape private events, but there are critical things that occur within an organism's skin that should not be excluded from our understanding of verbal behavior (Catania, 2007, p.9). Intraverbals are often taught using fill in the blank phrases and WH-questions. All three processes, he argued, were examples of parallel processes of selection by consequences. That is, classification alone does little to further the analysisthe functional relations controlling the operants outlined must be analyzed consistent with the general approach of a scientific analysis of behavior. Winokur (1978) is one example of research about echoic relations. WebPencil, paper, glue, scissors Name some foods. endobj According to the journal Analysis of Verbal Behavior, verbal operants are the basic language and communication abilities that children may be trained to apply in any situation. WebVerbal Behavior is a 1957 book by psychologist B. F. Skinner, in which he describes what he calls verbal behavior, or what was traditionally called linguistics. WebDate: _____ ABLLS-R INTRAVERBALS Name: _____ 3 H4 Animal sounds Make dog sounds Make cat sound Make pig sound Make cow sound Make sheep sound Supplementary stimulation is a discussion to practical matters of controlling verbal behavior given the context of material which has been presented thus far. Intraverbals are often studied by the use of classic association techniques.[19]. The speaker responds to another person. A child comes into the kitchen where a mother is, and says: A child looks out of the window, turns to his mother and says: A mother asks her daughter: "What grade did you get in math?" An example might be that when a kid falls and starts bleeding, the caregiver tells them statements like, "you got hurt". Skinner has argued that his account of verbal behavior might have a strong evolutionary parallel. Chair, table, couch, shelf Name some buildings. xow=IF~47 H^2lc=8^|+8II[(jv_)P]_$^xK3vM>L_fM8r#p 7`34o)t@t.l$Z88@H85,YBbs~0?@]E@qf`oL@` z endstream endobj 107 0 obj 364 endobj 93 0 obj << /Type /Page /Parent 85 0 R /Resources 94 0 R /Contents 98 0 R /TrimBox [ 36 36 630 819 ] /MediaBox [ 0 0 666 855 ] /CropBox [ 0 0 666 855 ] /Rotate 0 >> endobj 94 0 obj << /ProcSet [ /PDF /Text /ImageB ] /Font << /F1 101 0 R /F3 96 0 R /F4 97 0 R /F12 100 0 R >> /XObject << /Im1 102 0 R >> /ExtGState << /GS1 104 0 R >> /ColorSpace << /Cs6 95 0 R >> >> endobj 95 0 obj [ /ICCBased 105 0 R ] endobj 96 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Encoding /MacRomanEncoding /BaseFont /Times-Roman >> endobj 97 0 obj << /Type /Font /Subtype /Type1 /Encoding /WinAnsiEncoding /BaseFont /Times-Bold >> endobj 98 0 obj << /Length 1329 /Filter /FlateDecode >> stream Intraverbals are often considered more complex verbal behavior, as compared to requesting, labeling, and receptive identification. A loud knock at the door, may be a mand "open the door" and a servant may be called by a hand clap as much as a child might "ask for milk". Behavior under the control of verbal stimuli, New combinations of fragmentary responses. Reported resources will be reviewed by our team. Tact is the most useful form of verbal behaviour to other listeners, as it extends the listeners contact with the environment. If you need expert assistance with discrimination training for your child, consider reaching out to Songbird today. <>/XObject<>/ProcSet[/PDF/Text/ImageB/ImageC/ImageI] >>/MediaBox[ 0 0 540 720] /Contents 4 0 R/Group<>/Tabs/S>> This means that the child will be able to use discrimination in their day-to-day functioning across items, labels, names, etc., as mentioned above. Cooper, Heron, & Herward (2020) give a variety of examples of intraverbals: answering questions, telling stories, and recalling memories. When: February Some of the typical duties within the role include: planning, development, and monitoring of treatments for behavioral challenges; maintaining records of client progress and status, consulting with and teaching instructional team members; collaboration with families, related service providers, and other agencies; and conducting with periodic service reviews to evaluate the effectiveness of treatment programs. Word-associates occurred as intrusion errors reliably more often than did non-associates in a paced recall task. There is also a Verbal Behavior Special Interest Group (SIG)[40] of the Association for Behavior Analysis (ABA) which has a mailing list.[41]. ?Q.UeEnIClm,Tq|$aIws:!R>}H8M pB IFVG;I&Ix}QQHCHID0!G0}8`:OOsn,|q'1k=h~_'N5Wee6A6N\uvcC$5yesi4([Z_vqJV"L;vLpxItu1rHjYI5GHOsa/a{&'=}a>V{ RrmVjCK_\9kyplp+IY}oCMQ(eO%q$UVk:))IF&0{i`8:Cvd Discrimination training in ABA therapy is based on language skills are used in autism training. Another method is the "collateral response" associated with the private stimulus. 21 Engel Injection Molding Machines (28 to 300 Ton Capacity), 9 new Rotary Engel Presses (85 Ton Capacity), Rotary and Horizontal Molding, Precision Insert Molding, Full Part Automation, Electric Testing, Hipot Testing, Welding. 5 0 obj He introduced this concept into his book Verbal Behavior with the concept of the echoic. Audience control is developed through long histories of reinforcement and punishment. Emission is a yes/no measure, however the other threeenergy-level, speed, repetitioncomprise possible indications of relative strength.[15]. . Private events are events accessible to only the speaker. endobj Skinner (1957) acknowledged two major dilemmas. The child is then taught to select the shoe when the direction is placed to touch the shoe. Communication boards can be used as a bonding experience between parents and children. Applied behavior analysts have many evidence-based tools and techniques available to them when designing and implementing individualized treatment plans. For example, a phone conversation or e-mail exchange between two people consistsof one person saying or writing something,and the other person responding to Echoic: the repeating of a sound or word when present with the discriminative stimulus (SD) of say. Today, applied behavior analysts use a blend of augmentative and alternative communication (AAC) interventions, including the picture exchange communication system (PECS), speech-generating devices (SGDs), sign language, and communication boards, to help children with autism learn how to communicate. . This format is ideal for presentation on a white board or printed as a Seeing, hearing, feeling, touching, tasting, smelling. I teach students to respond to commonly used phrases by omitting the last word and prompting them to repeat the final word. We are designing a society where every child can experience exceptional care at home, personalized to their unique needs. Chomsky's review has been further argued to misrepresent the work of Skinner and others, including by taking quotes out of context. % It is a behavior under the functional control of a verbal stimulus. Verbal Behavior is a 1957 book by psychologist B. F. Skinner, in which he describes what he calls verbal behavior, or what was traditionally called linguistics. [6][7][8] Many research papers and applied extensions based on Verbal Behavior have been done since its publication.[9][10][11]. This term is most commonly used in ABA therapy. As the skill is obtained, the field can be increased to practice scanning and greater discriminating ability. 3 0 obj However, it is harder for the verbal community to shape the verbal behavior associated with private events (Catania, 2007, p.403). For example, in learning a new language, a teacher might say "parsimonious" and then say "can you say it?" Be aware of how the environment is set up before presenting directions. If they did, the verbal behavior would be classified as echoic or copying-a-text, neither of which would result in a useful conversation. There are many examples of intraverbal behavior such as the ability to answer questions, tell stories, describe events, solve problems, engage in debates, recall the past, and talk about the future. This will cause the child to only understand that one specific picture is a dog. When the therapy does take hold, however, the benefits can be remarkable. The main verbal operants will be explained using an ABC chart: A= Antecedent (what happens before the child speaks) B= Behavior (what the child said) C= Consequence (what happens after the child speaks) MAND The first verbal operant is the Mand. b:)qgMt~v?k%6Ks7RqW7gbJ!Cg* social The Autism Society of Wisconsin defines AAC as any non-vocal form of communication that supplements or replaces vocal speech in learners with communication impairments. There are two categories of AAC systems: Selection-based (SB) and Topography-based (TB). This resource includes a ready-to-use interactive activity students can complete on any device. I love how you asked Johnny how old he was!), Tips to Keep Your Child Cautious Yet Calm During the COVID-19 Pandemic, How to Help Your Child Adjust to Summer During COVID 19. This will assist in breaking the routine of constantly repeating everything that is said to them. to induce an echoic response. [46][47] Behavior analysts have been working on developing ideas based on Verbal Behaviour for fifty years, and despite this, experience difficulty explaining generative verbal behavior.[48]. We can respond to new audiences (new stimuli) as we would to similar audiences with whom we have a history. For example; a red ball will elicit a response of ball or red ball. 4L'aP The son says that he received an A plus. Mand is verbal behavior under functional control of satiation or deprivation (that is, motivating operations) followed by characteristic reinforcement often specified by the response. [3], Skinner's analysis of verbal behavior drew heavily on methods of literary analysis.